© Cor Faber en Ellen Bijma
Last update website march 2024
FDR and the Spanish Civil War
The
thesis
goes
that
without
the
Spanish
Civil
War,
Hitler's
Germany
would
have
won
World
War
II.
debatable?
Secure.
Unlikely?
Not
that
either.
The
involvement
of
the
United
States
deserves
some
extra
attention.
As
one
of
the
signatories
of
the
non-intervention
pact,
that
country
was
also not allowed to provide military aid.
Not
that
President
Roosevelt
was
waiting
for
that.
The
Civil
War
had
been
given
various
labels,
one
of
which
was
that
fascism
would
be
against
communism.
Roosevelt
didn't
want
anything
from
either
of
them, so they just sort it out there.
If
you
also
consider
that
during
the
1920s
and
1930s
the
United
States
had
a
policy
of
isolating
itself
from
the
rest
of
the
world
–
“Fortress
America”, us and the rest – then the picture is a bit more complete. .
Crucially,
the
Catholics,
who
sided
with
Franco,
had
significant
influence in its policy and implementation.
In
the
course
of
1937
Roosevelt's
picture
of
the
situation
changed.
No
longer
was
fascism
against
communism
but
now
democracy
against
dictatorship.
The
influence
of
his
wife
Eleanor
in
particular
played
an
important
part
in
this.
She
was
friends
with
people
like
Ernest
Hemingway,
who
had
cooperated
in
the
film
The
Spanish
Earth
by
the
Dutch
filmmaker
Joris
Ivens.
The
film
was
shot
in
the
middle
of
1937
and
gave
an
impression
of
the
situation
in
Spain
at
that
time.
The
film
was screened in the living room of the White House.
Also
contributing
to
changing
the
image
of
Roosevelt
was
the
news
that
reached
him
of
the
horrific
bombing
of
the
Basque
town
of
Guernika
(Gernika
in
Basque).
The
town
was
almost
bombed
to
the
ground
by
the
German
Condor
Legion
in
particular.
Hermann
Goering
wanted
to
know
what
'carpet
bombing'
would
psychologically
do
to
the
population.
The
Luftwaffe
also
tested
incendiary
bombs.
Goering
was
the
2nd
person
next
to
Hitler
and
wanted
to
show
that
he
had
to
stay
that way.
Also
contributing
to
changing
the
image
of
Roosevelt
was
the
news
that
reached
him
of
the
horrific
bombing
of
the
Basque
town
of
Guernika
(Gernika
in
Basque).
The
town
was
almost
bombed
to
the
ground
by
the
German
Condor
Legion
in
particular.
Hermann
Goering
wanted
to
know
what
'carpet
bombing'
would
psychologically
do
to
the
population.
The
Luftwaffe
also
tested
incendiary
bombs.
Goering
was
the
2nd
person
next
to
Hitler
and
wanted
to
show
that
he
had
to
stay
that way.
Roosevelt
realized
that
the
United
States
could
no
longer
remain
aloof
from
world
events
and
has
tried
to
get
out
of
the
non-intervention
pact.
The
opposition
from
the
Catholic
quarter
has
always
been
able
to
stop
this. That party has even blocked plans for humanitarian aid.
As
a
result,
Roosevelt
tried
to
organize
a
number
of
actions
in
a
personal
capacity.
Although
this
went
through
front
men,
publicity
about
these
plans
would
have
cost
him
politically.
Unfortunately,
these
plans came to nothing.
The
United
States
was
not
yet
a
superpower
at
that
time.
Of
course
there
was
a
military
apparatus,
but
that
was
not
much.
Because
of
the
turnaround
in
Roosevelt's
thinking
–
“we
can't
keep
ourselves
aloof
from
world
events”
–
the
build-up
of
that
military
apparatus
has
been
accelerated.
It
is
therefore
certainly
not
improbable
that
without
the
Spanish
Civil
War,
the
United
States
could
not
have
played
the
part
it
did
during
World
War
II.
For
the
republican
government
in
Spain,
however, that came too late.